Skip to content

The Rules Reward Psychopaths. Change the Rules Where You Live.

What a cauliflower from the market in Ortigueira has to do with who gets to power

Jonas
Jonas
— 5 min read
The Rules Reward Psychopaths. Change the Rules Where You Live.
Photo by Jonathan Cooper / Unsplash

Table of Contents

A few years ago I was sitting with a friend at the Dortmund-Ems Canal in Münster. We talked about the world, about the rampant inequality, and about how seemingly sociopathic or psychopathic people get to power.

Sometimes I see how people in leadership positions act, and I just think: "What the fuck?"

So we developed this theory, one that I've pondered with other friends before: maybe we are ruled by psychopaths.

The logic behind the theory:
You get richer if you're greedier and show less empathy, and then you can use that money to influence the rules of the game. That's how you amass power and money.

At that time I still thought it was a theory.

A few weeks ago I listened to an episode of The Great Simplification, Nate Hagens' podcast about how energy, ecology and the economy play together. Its thesis is that we will live a simpler life in the future, either by design or by force.

His guest was Greg Elliott, a systems theorist who wrote The Psychopathic Selection Hypothesis. It finally gave me words for what we were theorising sitting at the canal. And it moved me away from blaming the psychopathic people to look at the rules of the game.

What the numbers say (and what they don't)

About 1.2% of people score as psychopaths on the standard checklist. In a study of corporate professionals, it was 3.9%. Both numbers are from the episode.

That's 3 times as many. It also means that about 96 out of 100 corporate professionals are not psychopaths.

So "psychopaths run the world" is too simple. Elliott's point is a different one, and I find it more useful: institutions can act cold and deceptive even when most people inside them are decent.

Why? Because the incentives select for it. If the goal is making the most profit, and you make more money by exhibiting psychopathic traits (e.g., cheating, not being empathetic), then that's what you get.

The conditions for this to happen lie in the size and distance of the group:

In a small group, like the tribes we lived in for most of human history, cheating costs you your reputation.

In a global supply chain, the cheater stays anonymous.

Elliott calls this "inverted boundary conditions". As I understood it: the feedback that kept us cooperative changes to the opposite once the group gets big and anonymous enough.

This is one of the reasons why I think local economies within bioregions (regions defined by their rivers, mountains and culture) are the future. They make the feedback loops small again.

How the game traps good people

Knowing all this doesn't get you out.

Elliott calls it entrapment games: you stay in a system because leaving costs more than staying. The decent manager keeps the job in an institution that acts psychopathic. The farmer keeps selling to the supermarket that squeezes him.

These institutions win on abstract scores like profit and GDP while the real thing gets worse. GDP goes up when an oil spill destroys a coast and needs to get cleaned and rebuilt.

Elliott's name for this is symbolic fitness: being good at collecting the symbols (money, status, market share), no matter what happens to the soil or the coastline.

We can wait for better leaders at the top. Or we can change the size and the rules of the game we're in.

I'm going with the second one. Here are 4 dials you can turn where you live.

1. Spend your money where they know your name

I buy my vegetables from Quique at the market in Ortigueira. Just before writing this, I had a nice stew with his cauliflower.

Quique knows me, and he knows I'll be back next week. If his vegetables were bad, I'd tell him. And in a town this size, word travels.

That's reputation, back in the deal.

With a supermarket chain, there are so many steps between me and whoever grew the cauliflower that harm has plenty of places to hide.

How to start: find one place to buy where they'll learn your name. A market stall, a bakery, the kiosk at the corner.

2. Measure something real next to the money

Money is a score. The soil under your feet and the people around you are the real thing.

So pick something you can see with your own eyes and keep track of it. And do some things off the ledger: barter, return a favour, make something yourself.

Here in the community, when people have a birthday, usually what you give is plants for their garden: some seedling that you have grown, some nice plant you have collected the seeds from. It's a beautiful present that doesn't cost money, but it represents care.

3. Lower your exit costs

The trap works as long as you have no alternative. So build alternatives.

Learn skills your community needs. And build mutual aid with some structure: co-ops, machine banks (neighbours sharing machines), time banks (you trade hours with each other).

The more options you have, the less a single employer or buyer can trap you.

For me that was lowering my living costs by moving to the countryside (where I wanted to live anyways). It helped me stretch my runway with the little money I had available, while learning skills and giving me time to start this newsletter and my self-employment business.

4. Write the rules of your local game, and put a date on them

I can't rewrite the rules of the global economy. But coop bylaws, association statutes and town rules are written by people like you and me.

Lucas and I are founding an association for our bioregion, the Biorrexión Cantábrica, so I'm in the middle of this right now.

My favourite safeguard: put a date in the calendar to revisit the rules. Rules drift toward whoever benefits from them. A fixed date gives everyone else a moment to pull them back.

The Governance Canvas by Tijn and Ernestine helps you design this for your context.

Where small goes wrong

Small doesn't automatically mean good. (I learned that in an ecovillage.)

Galicia has its own word for it: caciquismo, the rule of the local boss who hands out jobs and favours and collects votes in return. Villages have their own tyrannies. Gossip, conformity, the family that owns half the land.

That's why the 4th dial matters most to me. A small group only keeps a psychopath in check when the rest of the group can still change the rules.

So some rules have to stay big. I think that's fine. The dials above are the ones you and I can influence. The change starts in the small fractals and radiates outward.

Try this

Pick one of the dials this month.

The easiest: find one place to buy from where they'll learn your name.

Or, if you're part of a co-op or an association, put a "revisit the rules" date in its calendar.

PS: Here is the full podcast episode on the psychopath topic.

Emotional IntelligenceLeadershipPersonal DevelopmentSystems Thinking

Jonas

Hi, I am Jonas. After a "crisis of meaning" I've started a journey of finding out how to live a more meaningful and joyful life. I am sharing my story and thoughts here.

Comments


Related Posts

Members Public

From Leadership to Healership – What an African Elder Taught a Room of European Weavers [#42]

Ubuntu, becoming naturalized to place, and why I’d lead my old lacrosse team differently today.

From Leadership to Healership – What an African Elder Taught a Room of European Weavers [#42]
Members Public

How Falling Into a Pool Taught Me What Community Is Worth [#40]

Unlearning my individualistic programming

How Falling Into a Pool Taught Me What Community Is Worth [#40]
Members Public

4 Paradigm Shifts We Need To Invite To Co-Create a More Beautiful Future [#39]

I think about the future almost every day.

4 Paradigm Shifts We Need To Invite To Co-Create a More Beautiful Future [#39]